Page 1 of 1

September TOTM suggestions

PostPosted: Sat Aug 27, 2011 5:08 pm
by Dally
How about some suggestions for September's TOTM? Rather than specific tunes, perhaps we could choose one of several catagories.

Peacock tunes
NPS Book 1
Billy Pigg
Tom Clough

It's never too late to post a TOTM performance. I hope to get "Peacock Follows the Hen" on the NSP posted this weekend.

Re: September TOTM suggestions

PostPosted: Mon Aug 29, 2011 9:57 am
by OldTomsRant
Hi,

How about the following:

Peacock - Cuddy Claw'd Her
NPS Book 1 - Whittle Dene Hornpipe (because it's often overlooked)
Billy Pigg - no preference - not my cup of tea any more
Tom Clough - Shadows

Alternatively, how about Old Tom's Rant - it's from the Clough repertoire, yet to me has all the hallmarks of a Peacock composition?

Chris

Re: September TOTM suggestions

PostPosted: Mon Aug 29, 2011 10:01 am
by OldTomsRant
Just realised I missed the point of John's post - please ignore my earlier suggestions.

Category-wise I'd vote for Peacock for September, then maybe at a later date we could look at the Clough versions of Peacock's settings.

Chris

Re: September TOTM suggestions

PostPosted: Wed Aug 31, 2011 11:28 pm
by Dally
The consensus for September's TOTM is Peacock, specifically "Cuddy Claw'd Her".
This tune can be played on the Northumbrian half-long pipes (which I think should be called the Northumbrian twice as long pipes), as well as the Northumbrian smallpipes.
Remember, you can post any month's tune at any time. I hope to have my NSP "Peacock follows the Hen" up soon.

Re: September TOTM suggestions

PostPosted: Thu Sep 01, 2011 3:12 pm
by Matt Seattle
Cuddy Claw'd Her - OK, if a 'consensus' is reached by three people!! But there is little rationale for recommending Peacock's setting to players of Border pipes, as it is one of his tunes which are so obviously 'adapted' to smallpipes by the replacement of all the low F naturals - with high e, of all possibilities.

It's not a tune I've gone for so far myself, but Dixon's setting is convincing, and one I've heard convincingly played by Pete Stewart and Dave Faulkner. The Clough setting is also worth serious consideration: it has the authority not only of the Cloughs but of the 'Charlton' book, presumably from one of John Armstrong of Carrick's mss, and also of the enigmatic Reavely ms., presumed to be roughly contemporary with Peacock. The very lightly 'unadapted' version is in the current edition of the 'little yellow book'.

And yes I'm working on all the tunes but don't have a camera!!

Re: September TOTM suggestions

PostPosted: Fri Sep 02, 2011 6:48 pm
by Dally
This is a very nice recording posted by Edric Ellis's on the NSP NG:
http://soundcloud.com/edric-ellis/cuddy ... r-1st-sept

Re: September TOTM suggestions

PostPosted: Fri Sep 02, 2011 7:00 pm
by Dally
Matt Seattle wrote:Cuddy Claw'd Her - OK, if a 'consensus' is reached by three people!! But there is little rationale for recommending Peacock's setting to players of Border pipes, as it is one of his tunes which are so obviously 'adapted' to smallpipes by the replacement of all the low F naturals - with high e, of all possibilities.

It's not a tune I've gone for so far myself, but Dixon's setting is convincing, and one I've heard convincingly played by Pete Stewart and Dave Faulkner. The Clough setting is also worth serious consideration: it has the authority not only of the Cloughs but of the 'Charlton' book, presumably from one of John Armstrong of Carrick's mss, and also of the enigmatic Reavely ms., presumed to be roughly contemporary with Peacock. The very lightly 'unadapted' version is in the current edition of the 'little yellow book'.

And yes I'm working on all the tunes but don't have a camera!!


Thanks for the insight into the different settings, Matt. I've been playing through the different settings and so far the Cloughs' has caught my attention over the others for NSP, because of the Fnat and final variation. For BP or SSP, it's Dixon for me...at least for now.